Integrated Grid Planning
Integrated Grid Planning Symposium
November 15-16, 2017
The Hawaiian Electric Companies developed a Grid Modernization Strategy, which was filed with the Hawaii Public Utilities Commission (PUC) on August 29, 2017. As part of the Grid Modernization Strategy, the Companies proposed a new Integrated Grid Planning process that integrates the needs at all levels of the system: customer, bulk power resources, transmission, and distribution. The comprehensive, customer-focused, and cooperative grid planning process would engage customers and stakeholders at key junctures in the integrated resource, transmission, and distribution planning effort.
Through Order No. 34696 accepting the Hawaiian Electric Companies' Power Supply Improvement Plans, the PUC directed the Hawaiian Electric Companies to file with the commission "a report that details the Companies' planning approach and schedule for the next round of integrated planning. The Companies shall file this report with the Commission no later than March 1, 2018."
A grid planning Symposium focusing on leading practices and related planning technologies and tools across the U.S. was held as part of this effort to develop a new integrated grid planning process for Hawaii. You can view our Integrated Grid Planning webpage for the latest information.
Welcome: On November 15 & 16, 2017, the Hawaiian Electric Companies held an Integrated Grid Planning Symposium. The Symposium was attended by roughly 150 stakeholders in person and by another roughly 80 via webinar on Day 1 and 50 on Day 2. Copies of panelist presentations can be found on this web page, and recordings of the webinar will be available shortly.
Objective:
This symposium will discuss the state of the art for Integrated Grid Planning (IGP) across the U.S. Also, inform attendees of the processes, methods, and technology being used and lessons learned. Hawaiian Electric is pleased to host this symposium with support from the US Department of Energy.
Day 1 Agenda:
8:30-8:40 Welcome & Introduction
- Colton Ching, Hawaiian Electric
8:40-8:50 Opening Remarks
- David Ige, Governor, State of Hawaii
8:50-10:00 Plenary: Objectives for Hawaii's IGP - Moderated discussion of the objectives for Hawaii's IGP process.
Moderator: Colton Ching
- Dean Nishina, Hawaii Consumer Advocate
- Stanford Carr, Developer
- Kyle Datta, Ulupono
- Luis Salaveria, DBEDT
10:15-11:30 Panel 1: Integrated Grid Planning - Introduction to IGP including the process, methods, technology and stakeholder engagement considerations. Overview of activity underway in U.S. to provide context.
Moderator: Paul De Martini, Newport
- Jeff Smith, EPRI - Download slides (PDF)
- Juliet Homer, PNNL - Download slides (PDF)
- Paul Centolella, Fmr. Ohio Commissioner - Download slides (PDF)
- Mark Esguerra, PG&E - Download slides (PDF)
12:30-1:45 Panel 2: Distribution Planning & Hosting Capacity - Introduction to distribution planning regarding current methods and changes being implemented to address DER growth. Includes discussion of use cases, methods and applications of hosting capacity in the U.S.
Moderator: Juliet Homer, PNNL
- Samir Succar, ICF - Download slides (PDF)
- Mark Esguerra, PG&E - Download slides (PDF)
- Sky Stanfield, IREC - Download slides (PDF)
- Jeff Smith, EPRI - Download slides (PDF)
- Marc Asano, Hawaiian Electric - Download slides (PDF)
2:00-3:15 Panel 3: Locational Value - Discussion of emerging policies and practices for determining locational value across the U.S. along with appropriate context to understand implications for Hawaii.
Moderator: Paul De Martini, Newport
- Samir Succar, ICF - Download slides (PDF)
- Juliet Homer, PNNL - Download slides (PDF)
- Brian Horii, E3 - Download slides (PDF)
- Mark Esguerra, PG&E - Download slides (PDF)
3:15-4:25 Panel 4: Stakeholder Engagement - Discussion of relevant best practices in U.S. for stakeholder engagement in integrated grid planning and insights from Hawaii's experience.
Moderator: Colton Ching
- Cynthia Rezentes, Community Advocate - - Download slides (PDF)
- Donna Attanasio, GWU Law - Download slides (PDF)
- Samir Succar, ICF - Download slides (PDF)
- Paul De Martini, Newport - Download slides (PDF)
4:25-4:30 Summary Remarks
- Colton Ching
Day 2 Agenda:
8:00-8:15 Day's Welcome & Open Remarks
- Colton Ching
8:15-9:30 Panel 5: Grid Scale and DER Resources - Discussion on DER and grid scale resources and their potential in Hawaii.
Moderator: Todd Kanja, Hawaiian Electric
- Barry Mather, NREL - Download slides (PDF)
- Therese Klaty, Hawaiian Electric - Download slides (PDF)
- Mahesh Morjaria, First Solar - Download slides (PDF)
- Charles Vaughan, AES Energy Storage - Download slides (PDF)
9:45-11:00: Panel 6: Resource Planning Methods - Discussion on the integration of DER and grid scale resources and the optimization techniques.
Moderator: Bob Zavadil, EnerNex
- Mike Yamane, KIUC - Download slides (PDF)
- Ren Orans, E3 - Download slides (PDF)
- Gary Dorris, Ascend Analytics - Download slides (PDF)
- Lisa Giang, Hawaiian Electric - Download slides (PDF)
11:00-12:15 Lunch (12:00 Lunchtime Speaker: Commissioner Lorraine Akiba, Hawaii PUC)
- Lorriane Akiba, Commissioner, Hawaii PUC - Download slides (PDF)
12:15-1:30 Panel 7: State of IGP Technology (distribution integration analysis) - Discuss technology capabilities and relevant examples.
Moderator: Juliet Homer, PNNL
- Larry Trussel, DNVGL - Download slides (PDF)
- Kevin Kushman, Integral Analytics - Download slides (PDF)
- Marcelo Sandoval, ProsumerGrid - Download slides (PDF)
- Lulu Young, GridUnity - Download slides (PDF)
- Aram Shumavon, Kevala - Download slides (PDF)
1:45-3:00 Panel 8: State of IGP Technology (reliability, resilience & system security) - Discuss technology capabilities and relevant examples.
Moderator: Bob Zavadil, EnerNex
- Derek Stenclik, GE - Presented by Bob Zavadil - Download slides (PDF)
- Erik Ela, EPRI - Download slides (PDF)
- Dean Arakawa, Hawaiian Electric - Download slides (PDF)
- Vahan Gevorgian, NREL - Download slides (PDF)
3:00-4:15 Closing Insights Plenary - Discuss key takeaways from the symposium for Hawaii's IGP
Moderator: Colton Ching, Hawaiian Electric
- Dean Nishina, Consumer Advocate
- Donna Attanasio, GWU Law
- Juliet Homer, PNNL
- Paul Centolella, Fmr. Ohio Commissioner
4:15-4:30 Closing Remarks
- Colton Ching